Best of Westchester Winner 2024 “Best American Bakery” and “Best Cupcake”
Best of Westchester Winner 2023 for “Best Cupcake”
Best of Westchester Winner 2022 “Best Cupcake” and “Best muffins”
Best of Westchester Winner 2021 “Best Bakery” and “Best Cinnamon Buns”
Best of Westchester Winner 2020 for “Best American Bakery” and “Best Pie”
Best of Westchester 2019 Winner for “Best Bakery” and “Best Pies”
Best of Westchester 2018 Winner for “Best Bakery”
Best of Westchester 2017 Winner for “Best Bakery” and “Best Chocolate Chip Cookie”
Best of Westchester 2016 Winner for “Best Pies”
Best of Westchester 2015 Winner for “Best Bakery” & “Best Cupcake”
Best of Westchester 2014 Winner for “Apple Turnovers”
Best of Westchester 2013 Winner for “Best Cinnamon Rolls”
Best of Westchester 2018 Winner for “Best Bakery”
Best Bakery| Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
Susan O’Keefe was awarded once again as a best bakery of Westchester in the Best of Westchester. Handmade pies that are made fresh and from scratch every day.
Best of Westchester 2017 Winner for “Best Bakery” & “Best Chocolate Chip Cookie”
Editors’ Picks 2017: Best of Westchester Winner Baked by Susan Chocolate Chip CookieChocolate Chip Cookie | Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
Our chocolate chip cookies are made from the richest chocolate and cookie dough. We make them fresh every single day and they are one of our favorites here at Baked By Susan!
Best of Westchester 2016 Winner for “Best Pies”
Editors’ Picks 2016: Best of Westchester Winner Baked by Susan PiesPies | Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
We offer a wide variety of quality pies for farm markets, retail bake shops and the food service industry. Our pies are made by hand, from scratch every single day. We use only unsalted butter, flour, water and salt for our crust and we use local fruit in season whenever possible. Trust us, you will see and taste the difference!
Best of Westchester 2015 Winner for “Best Bakery” & “Best Cupcake”
Editors’ Picks 2015: Best of Westchester Winner Baked by Susan CupcakesCupcakes | Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
This year Susan O’Keefe was awarded Best of Westchester for “Best Bakery” and “Best Cupcake.” She offers classic ($2.50) and specialty ($3) cupcake flavors, as well as some gluten free and vegan options.
Best of Westchester 2014 Winner for “Apple Turnovers”
Editors’ Picks 2014: Best of Westchester Winner Baked by Susan Apple TurnoversApple Turnovers | Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
Westchester Magazine
In last year’s Best Of Issue, it was Susan O’Keefe’s cinnamon rolls that had us slobbering; this year, it’s her turnovers ($3), made with homemade puff-pastry dough (requiring a three-hour prep time!) and apples fresh from DuBois Farms in Highland, New York (Ulster County). They’re not cloyingly sweet, and the ratio of dough to apples is spot-on.
Best of Westchester (Editors’ Pick) 2013 Winner for “Best Cinnamon Rolls”
Editors’ Picks 2013: Best of Westchester Winner Baked by Susan Cinnamon BunsCinnamon Rolls | Baked by Susan
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
914-862-0874
Westchester Magazine
These hand-made, hand-rolled cinnamon rolls are not for lightweights. They are dense, rich, made with “lot and lots of butter,” and topped with a cream cheese icing. And, speaking of weight, we asked owner Susan O’Keefe to weigh one of these babies and it tipped the scales at a whopping six ounces. But seriously, if you are shopping around for cinnamon rolls, we really doubt you are counting calories.
Video: Best of Westchester winner for “Best Cinnamon Rolls”, Editors’ Pick 2013
