914-862-0874

Baked by Susan

Handmade Old-Fashioned Baked Goods Made Fresh Daily

Cakes

detail-susan-baked-me-a-cake

Cake maker, cake maker bake me a cake! 

WE ALSO MAKE WEDDING CAKES!

All cakes made to order. Please allow 48 hours notice (more notice needed during holidays). Call us for you next birthday or special event.

Classic Cake Flavors: vanilla, chocolate, red velvet 

Cakes iced with Vanilla Swiss Buttercream, Chocolate Swiss Buttercream, Chocolate Icing, Mocha Swiss Buttercream or Cream Cheese Icing.

Specialty fillings: Mocha Swiss Buttercream, Lemon Curd, Lemon Mousse, Chocolate Mousse, Chocolate Ganache, Pastry Cream, Chocolate Pudding, Raspberry Preserves, Raspberry Cake Filling, Raspberry Swiss Buttercream, Strawberry Swiss Buttercream, Whipped Cream, Cannoli filling.

  • 6″ round double layer, serves 6-8
  • 8″ round double layer, serves 12-14
  • 10″round double layer, serves 24-28
  • 12″ round double layer, serves 40+
  • ¼ sheet (9×13) one layer, no filling, serves 24-30
  • 1/4 sheet double layer, serves 30+
  • ½ sheet one layer, no filling, serves 40-50
  • 1/2 sheet double layer, serves 50+
  • Full Sheet Cake, one layer, no filling, serves 80-100

*Call for pricing*

Additional cost for special decorations

 

Specialty Flavors:

  • Carrot Cake Carrot Cake iced with Cream Cheese icing – does not have nuts or raisins but we are NOT A NUT FREE BAKERY
  • Cheesecake 9″ Made with our own Gingersnap crust
  • Chocolate Caramel Delight Two layers of Chocolate Cake and Caramel Buttercream
  • Coconut Cake Two layers of Vanilla Cake, iced and filled with Coconut Buttercream
  • Flourless Chocolate Cake 9″ Gluten Free. Chocolate deliciousness
  • Lemon Drop Two layers of vanilla cake, filled with lemon curd and iced with swiss buttercream
  • Marshmallow Monster Chocolate cake, filled with Marshmallow Buttercream and iced with Chocolate Icing
  • Nutty Girl Two layers of chocolate cake, filled with peanut butter filling, iced with Chocolate Icing
  • Pretty in Pink A double layer of Chocolate Cake filled with house made raspberry cake filling, iced Raspberry Buttercream and a chocolate ganache drip
  • Strawberry Shortcake Vanilla cake, filled and iced with fresh whipped cream and fresh strawberries
  • The Maggie B Chocolate cake, filled and iced with whipped cream and drizzled with Chocolate Ganache
  •  Funfetti Two layers of funfetti cake filled and iced with funfetti sprinkles
  • Almond Joy Chocolate cake with almond joy filling iced and decorated with almonds and coconut
  • Cookie Dough Cake Two layers of vanilla cake filled with edible cookie dough, iced in swiss buttercream with edible cookie dough on top!

In the News

Serious Indulgence: Baked-By-Susan’s Classic Chocolate Treat

When my boys were little, I would marvel at how long it took me to pull out their winter coats, hats, matching mittens, and extra socks, Jan 7. Read More

Discover Westchester’s Best of the Best Over 20 Years

There’s a reason Baked by Susan was selected as a Best of Westchester winner every year since 2013: Everything is made from scratch daily, using all-natural, local ingredients and fruit in season with no preservatives. Jan 7. Read More

Baked By Susan Is Expanding Into a Brand New Croton Location

Baked by Susan is one of Westchester’s most prolific local bakeries. So prolific, in fact, that the much-loved shop is moving just a few blocks to a brand-new Croton-on-Hudson address with a Grand Opening scheduled for noon on Saturday, March 7. Read More

Best of Westchester 2013 Winner: Baked By Susan - Croton-on-Hudson, NY

Read More

Croton bakery is moving into larger space; grand opening (with free cupcakes) is March 7

The popular Croton-on-Hudson bakery, known for its cakes, cookies, cupcakes, pies, empanadas and more — not just in Croton but at many coffee shops throughout. Read More

Baked Goods, Nothing Added

Susan O’Keefe was looking for a commercial kitchen to expand her wholesale baking business when she came across a sunny retail space in Croton-on-Hudson that changed her perspective. Home to a series of pizza parlors.Read More

Baked by Susan

As a stay-at-home mom with three boys, Susan O’Keefe often baked for friends and even local restaurants. But what pushed her from “baker” to “bakery owner” was when she had the opportunity to make homemade cookies for the United Nations: she had to quickly come up with a company name and label.Read More

Baked by Susan Ribbon Cutting

Read More

Wanna chat? Call us at 914-862-0874

Hungry for something yummy? We aim to please! We're always up to something, whether it's new flavors, seasonal recipes or special events.
379 S. Riverside Ave. Croton on Hudson, NY, 10520
bow-2014Best of Westchester 2016
bow-2013bow-2014Best of Westchester 2016bow-2015
  • Best of Westchester Winner 2020 for Best American Bakery and Best Pie
  • 2019 Winner for "Best Bakery" & "Best Pies"
  • 2018 Winner for "Best Bakery"
  • 2017 Winner for "Best Bakery" & "Best Chocolate Chip Cookie"
  • 2016 Winner for "Best Pie"
  • 2015 Winner for “Best Bakery” & “Best Cupcake”
  • 2014 Winner for “Apple Turnovers”
  • 2013 Winner for “Best Cinnamon Rolls”