Order Custom Cakes with These 3 Easy Steps
1. Select from our list of cake flavors, icings, and fillings
2. Select your cake size
3. Let us know of any special decorations
At Baked by Susan, we bake our custom cakes fresh to order. Please allow a 48 hour notice.
ORDER NOW (914) 862-0874
Ensuring 100% Guest Satisfaction with Every Order
The cakes and cupcakes baked by Susan are delicious!! I have ordered b’day cakes for both my kids from her and cupcakes in bulk too! The treats are always yummy and beautiful. And Susan gives personal attention to each of the orders and will work with you to make sure you get what you want. I will definitely keep ordering from here!!
— Parul Awasthy
I just wanted to say how much we loved the vegan red velvet cake that Baked by Susan did for one of the employees I work with. As a vegan myself, I was so impressed with the texture and flavor, and the birthday boy was over the moon! I’m so glad my friend recommended you to me. I can’t wait to try the vegan brownies next! Thanks again!
— Susan Calabro
Best of Westchester 2018 Winner for “best Bakery”
Best of Westchester 2017 Winner for “Best Chocolate Chip Cookie”
Best of Westchester 2016 Winner for “Best Pies”
Best of Westchester 2015 Winner for “Best Cupcake”
Best of Westchester 2014 Winner for “Best Apple Turnovers”
Best of Westchester 2013 Winner for “Best Cinnamon Rolls”
Our custom cakes are good to the last bite!
Baked By Susan is an expert when it comes to custom cakes. If you have any questions about cakes, holiday cookies, desserts, birthday cakes, or our wholesale bakery options, and live in Croton on Hudson, Briarcliff Manor, Cortlandt Manor, Ossining, or Westchester, NY, contact Baked By Susan at: 914.862.0874